Sarah, He didn't claim he had proof of a proposed closure. He said that the Christie was under threat - due to the review. The same as the doctors said. Or get me a quote that says different. Everyone, Labour are now spinning the Christie issue in a disingenuous way to try and soothe their ire at losing the seat. If they hadn't taken Withington for granted then their 11 thousand majority would not have been overturned in just four years.