Sarah, So you don't believe him, or the Manchester Evening News that 60 doctors have said that the Christie is under threat. Fair enough. That doesn't make him a liar. http://www.manchesteronline.co.uk/men/news/s/157/157574_christie_blueprint_defies_nhs_chiefs.html or to pull out a little: "Last month the M.E.N. revealed how 60 doctors at Christie had signed a petition in protest at the review, which they say could threaten the future of Europe's largest cancer hospital. Medics fear health bosses have already made a decision behind closed doors to move cancer surgery, leukaemia, critical care and administration to nearby Manchester Royal Infirmary, which could spell the end for Christie."